You're currently browsing our buylist ← Return to Store

You're currently browsing our buylist ← Return to Store


View All

Search our buylist

Quick Search

Browse by Category

Buylist Policies:

·         We strive to offer the best possible prices for your trading cards. We offer payment via PayPal or Store Credit. Please note that if you select payment via PayPal, some fees will apply.

·         Buylists must be mailed directly to us and cannot be accepted by our Game Center or Vendor Booth staff. Please contact if you are looking to arrange an in person delivery.

·         Unless specifically noted, we only buy English language cards.

·         We do not accept signed or stamped cards. Any items sent to us with those markings will be graded as Heavily Played at best and will be priced accordingly.

·         All prices shown are for Near Mint cards, unless otherwise specified. Prices will be adjusted downward if we receive cards graded below that. If you would like to be notified of any and all grading adjustments before we finalize and pay you for your submission, please write "HOLD ORDER" in the Order Comments section during checkout.

·         If you have any questions or concerns about selling cards to us or have feedback on how we can improve our buylist, feel free to contact to let us know.

Our grading scale:

Near Mint: A card in Near Mint condition will show little to no wear. It may have a light scratch, small nick, or barely noticeable border wear. A foil card will have little to no clouding and retain most or all of its original gloss. 

Slightly Played: A card in Slightly Played condition will show visible, minor wear. It may have mild border or corner wear, minor bending, light scratching, small nicks, light scuffing, or very minor border creasing. A foil card may also have moderate clouding and have lost some of its original gloss.

Heavily Played: A card in Heavily Played condition will show easily visible, but not extreme wear. It may have extensive border or corner wear, moderate bending, moderate scratching, nicks, scuffing, moderate creasing, moderate whitening, slight inking along the borders, slight tearing along the borders, minor water damage, minor dirt buildup, or slight discoloration. A foil card may also have major clouding and have lost most of its original gloss.

Damaged: A card in Damaged condition will show easily visible, extreme wear. It may have major whitening, heavy inking, major creasing or tearing, extensive water damage, writing on the front or back, missing pieces, extensive dirt buildup, or extreme discoloration. A foil card may also have lost all of its original gloss.

We buy most cards graded below Near Mint at the following rates: 


Slightly Played

Heavily Played


Non-Foil Cards




Foil Cards




Old Expansions*




Additionally, we buy non-NM items at the following rates:

·         Any rare that we buy for $0.10 or less that arrives in worse than Near Mint condition will instead be bought for $0.05

·         Any common or uncommon that we buy for less than $0.05 that arrives in worse than Near Mint condition will instead be bought at our bulk rate.

How do I sell cards to Dolly’s Toys and Games? 

·         You can quickly and easily find the cards you wish to sell by using either our search bar or by browsing the product links in the upper left of the screen. Once you have located a card you are interested in selling to us, just add it to your Sell Cart. Please be aware that you must be in "Selling Mode" to sell cards to us.

·         To edit your Cart or Checkout, simply click the "View Buylist/Submit" link in the Cart Summary section.

·         Follow the system prompts to complete your sell order.

·         Wait for the confirmation email to arrive. After you submit your buylist, we have to double-check that we want to buy everything at the posted prices. Usually this takes less than one (1) business day, but please read this email carefully when it arrives because sometimes we do make changes. If you do not receive a confirmation email within two (2) business days, please contact us at so we can manually confirm the status of your buylist.

·         Please include a print out of your confirmation email with your package. Occasionally we receive buylists with no name on them and consequently we have a difficult time locating the seller. Do not let this happen to you!

·         Make sure that your cards are sorted in the exact order that they appear on your confirmation email. If your cards arrive out of order, please expect an additional delay of up to five (5) business days before completion of your buylist. Please note that in extreme cases such as buylists of several hundred cards that arrive in no order at all, we reserve the right to either return the entire order or else assess a penalty of up to 10% of the final value of your buylist. We will contact you before processing your buylist if we intend to return it or assess a penalty.

·         Remember to package your cards securely. We do not want your cards to be damaged during shipment and neither should you, so please take the time to make sure your cards are well packed and protected. Do not put cards in plastic zip lock bags or wrap them with rubber bands, as these will more than likely result in damage. We highly recommend packaging your cards in plastic card cases or boxes designed specifically to hold trading cards. Bubble mailers work well too, but please remember to secure the cards so that they do not become loose during transit. We also ask that you please not sleeve any cards listed at or below $5.00 in value. For cards above this value, sleeves are permitted but remember that we have to de-sleeve each card in order to grade it so removing your cards from sleeves will save us time and allow us to pay you faster!

·         All buylist submissions must be mailed directly to our processing facility. Please address all buylists to: 

Dolly’s Toys and Games
Attention: Buyer 
115 Montezuma Trail

Toronto ON M1V 1K4


·         While we do not require it, we strongly recommend that you purchase tracking and insurance for your package. Occasionally packages are lost or damaged in transit and we are not responsible for mistakes made by mail carriers, so in order to protect yourself and your package we encourage you to spend the extra couple dollars on both tracking and insurance.  

·         Although we understand that sometimes there are delays in sending cards to us, due to the constantly changing nature of card prices we ask that all buylists sent to us are received at our facility within seven (7) business days of their acceptance. After that time, any prices we have offered are subject to change. Your buylist will remain active in our system for three (3) weeks after which time accceptance is not guaranteed.

·         We will send an email to you when your package arrives at our facility. You will receive another email within two (2) business days once your cards have been graded and a final value has been determined. Please keep in mind that our posted prices are for Near Mint cards only. If you are uncomfortable receiving a reduced price for cards graded below Near Mint, please review our grading scale and closely inspect the cards you are sending to us before shipping. If you would like to be notified of any and all grading adjustments before we finalize and pay you for your submission, please write "HOLD ORDER" in the Order Comments section during checkout. 

·         In order to ensure that everyone who sells cards to us is completely satisfied with their experience, we email all sellers whose buylists depreciate by 25% or more in value due to downgrades in condition before we complete their submission. If we do not receive a reply within two (2) business days, we continue to process their submission as usual. If you would like to bypass this step in the event that your buylist will be downgraded below the 75% threshold, please include the note "SKIP DOWNGRADE" in the Order Comments section.

·         At the end of each business day we have a second associate double check each buylist to verify that it has been graded accurately. For this reason, please allow up to two (2) business days for us to send payment after your buylist has been graded.

·         If you want to change your buylist for any reason before sending it to us, for instance to remove an item from the list, please contact to inform us of the adjustment. If you wish to add cards, please submit a second buylist. Please feel free to include multiple buylists in one package, but remember to include the invoices for each one.

We buy bulk!

Don't see your cards listed? Don't worry, we buy bulk cards too. Dolly’s Toys and Games is currently paying the following prices for bulk:

Bulk Magic Rares: $0.10 each

Bulk Magic Mythic Rares: $0.25 each

Bulk Magic FOIL Rares: $0.20 each

Bulk Magic FOIL Mythic Rares: $0.50 each 

Bulk Magic FOIL Commons/Uncommons: $0.05 each 

Bulk Magic Battle for Zendikar Full Art Basic Land: $0.05 each

Bulk Magic Zendikar Full Art Basic Land: $0.10 each 


Please keep in mind that these prices are for bulk cards that are Near Mint and English. We will downgrade bulk cards that do not meet these requirements per the non-NM rates listed above, so please be careful before sending bulk cards in.